BackHomeNext
The Nature of Government

1b. Types of Government

Louis XIV, absolute monarch
Louis XIV, the King of France from 1643 until 1715, is the definition of an absolute monarch. His famous phrase, "I am the State," is an illustration of the power he wielded in France. Louis ruled through a mixture of fear and admiration, but in every case the law extended from himself.

"Off with his head!"

This is a favorite story line to show how cruel a king (or a sultan or emperor) can be. The rules in this type of government are pretty clear. Whatever the ruler says, goes. Of course, many people have had different ideas about how the ruler should govern, and those beliefs support totally different types of government. The rules shape the government's legitimacy, or the degree to which the people accept the authority of the government.

Rule by Man

Countries whose citizens are governed by the absolute decisions of the ruler have not necessarily been unhappy. A government whose king or queen rules justly and wisely may enjoy a great deal of legitimacy as long as the ruler's authority is accepted. Sometimes people may accept their leader because they are afraid of the consequences if they don't. In the words of Machiavelli, "It is better to be feared than loved." As long as the feared ruler is seen as bringing about prosperity or protecting the lives of his subjects, it is entirely possible that his people will be happy.

Niccolo Machiavelli
Niccolo Machiavelli wrote political works during the Renaissance. In The Prince, Machiavelli advised his audience that in a system of Rule by Man it was "better to be feared than loved."

An absolute ruler may be accepted because the people believe or accept the idea that God gave him/her the right to rule. This belief is known as divine right, which often has been associated with a monarchy, a form of government in which the power of the king or queen is hereditary. A similar idea legitimized the Chinese emperor, whose rule was threatened if his subjects perceived that he had lost the "mandate of heaven."

Rule by man can also take the shape of an oligarchy, or rule by a few elites whose right to rule is based on possession of wealth, social status, military position or achievement. A little more broadly based rule is by aristocracy (literally, "rule of the highest"), but if the type of government is "rule by man", their decisions are still arbitary and absolute.

Rule by Law

Rule by law exists in any political system in which those with power cannot make up all their own rules, but must follow an established code of law. In ancient times a Byzantine emperor established Justinian's Code, a set of laws named after him that lived on long after he died. We still follow parts of that code today. The Romans were also known for codifying laws, as was Napoleon, Emperor of France, many centuries later.

Bonaparte and the Code
Napoleon revised the French laws into a single unified code, known as the Code Napoleon. Under the French Empire, the code was implemented throughout Europe. Napoleon is seen in this painting standing next to a copy of the Code written on a scroll.

Today most governments at least claim to be ruled by law. The most common indication is the existence of a written constitution, but the most important question to ask is whether or not the constitution actually is the "blueprint" that determines how and what policies are made. For example, Nigeria officially is a democracy with a written constitution that one dictator after another has ignored. On the other hand, Great Britain has never had a constitution as a single written document, but has for centuries been governed by law. For much of their history, the English had a limited monarchy, or a king or queen who has followed rule of law.

So whether a king can order "off with his head!" depends on the type of government that is accepted in his country. If he sets the rules (rule by man), or if the accepted outside rules allow (rule by law), the victim doesn't have a chance.

On the Web
Machiavelli — Statesman and Political Thinker
It is better to be feared than loved. -Niccolo Machiavelli was a political theorist of the Renaissance era who presented his ideas on the realistic, and often dictatorial, running of a nation in The Prince. This Lucidcafe site gives a short biography of Machiavelli's life and a summary of his ideas, as well as links to electronic versions of his work. His ideas have influenced almost every leader of the modern world, especially brutal dictators like Hitler and Stalin.
Niccolo Machiavelli
Niccolo Machiavelli had a softer side that didn't get shown in The Prince. This HistoryPlace site gives a different take on Machiavelli's life and work, including an excerpt from his other major book, Discourses on Titus Livius, which deals with republics that are ruled by an active citizenry, like the United States.
Justinian — The Man and His Digest
Justinian was an emperor of Byzantium who oversaw the codification of the various Roman laws in order to make them less confusing. This biography from The online Encyclopedia of Roman Emperors tells the story of Justinian's rule.
Napoleon's Law — The Code Napoleon
Napoleon, despite being an emperor, ruled according to the laws of France. But he was also the one who wrote the laws in his Code Napoleon. This Napoleon Bonaparte Internet Guide page hosts links to several Code Napoleon sites.
The Divine Right of Kings
In the era of kings, many monarchs ruled according to a doctrine of "divine right," the idea that God gave them the power and authority to rule over their subjects. This Washington State University site explains the history of that philosophy.
The Guillotine
Both rule by man and rule by law need to be enforced, and mankind has come up with some pretty inventive ways of doing that. The guillotine is one of them. Check out the history of this device of death on this independent interactive website. Don't miss the amazing Flash presentation which makes this site one of the best on the Web.
del.icio.us Facebook Digg Furl Netscape Yahoo! My Web StumbleUpon Google Bookmarks Technorati BlinkList Newsvine ma.gnolia reddit Windows Live
BackHomeNext
historic documents, declaration, constitution, more